multitrack recording

I am recording in my church using a Behringer X32 output via a Behringer USB card (32 channels I/o) into Studio One. Everything works great EXCEPT when I record and immediate play the recording back through the exact same X32 mixer and dynamics that I just recorded from the recording sounds...

I have an M-480 as mentioned in the title, and I'm trying to record each track for a project. I have an old laptop running Windows 7 and was able to download Rolands REAC driver as well as Cakewalk (not sure if REAC driver was essential in the end?) and got it to work, but the old laptop is a...