"Stereo" recording -- you're fired?

Frank Koenig

Sophomore
Mar 7, 2011
187
0
16
Palo Alto, CA USA
www.dunmovin.com
Last Saturday night I attended a lovely performance of Beethoven's 9th, among other things, by the Peninsula Symphony at Flint Center in Cupertino. Down stage center was a tall stand with an X-Y pair of microphones. So far so good.

The trouble is that these mics looked for all the world like a pair of Earth Works omnis, the ones with the narrow snout that look like a measurement mic (I own an M-30, I know what they look like). What you might call a "very SDC". Strange, I thought, but what do I know?

After the concert I went back stage to the place the recordist usually hangs out to find him packing up his (nice, expensive) gear. I politely asked about what appeared to be a unique approach to getting a stereo recording and the poor chap appeared to have no clue. "It's what they sent me out with." He got out the fancy wooden box the Earth Works live in and the instruction sheet clearly said "omnidirectional". So it looks like the symphony got a pair of essentially identical mono recordings when they paid for stereo. Is there something I'm not getting here, or do they need to look for a new recordist?

Bewildered,

--Frank
 
Fired? I have a better idea. Maybe teach the guy something new and everyone wins except if you want the recording contract. I have shown a few far more experienced techs a thing or two about things they weren't aware of. If you approach it correctly they might end up being grateful.
I am a fan of mono for some unknown reason. Maybe its the few times I got burned by running a mono line with a stereo recording with hard panning. I guess I like the simplicity.
 
Last edited:
Fired? I have a better idea. Maybe teach the guy something new and everyone wins except

Good advice -- you are a kind and reasonable person. As it turns out I really don't have a dog in this fight beyond wanting the symphony not to be ripped off. They have a history of less than stellar oversight as a couple of years ago their executive director (not the maestro) managed to embezzle something like $200k of their funds. He's in the big house now.

http://www.mercurynews.com/crime-co...symphony-director-faces-16-years-embezzlement

Thanks all for confirming that I'm not the crazy one in this instance. I have let my friend in the orchestra know and she'll pass the concern up the chain.

Best,

--Frank