5K$ anyone?

Re: 5K$ anyone?

Marjan Milosevic said:
ATTENTION ALL SPEAKER MANUFACTURES!!!! Canadian Speaker Works will be running our shoot out again this summer 6 of your subs vs 6 of ours..
this will take place In Brampton, Ont Canada this summer $5,000.00 Bet winner take all..
Click to expand...
Looks like the speakers they use would have a very high Xmax.
Natural "Hyper Cardiod " pattern from a 2x18" bass reflex box, good trick...

Are there restrictions to the "shoot out" , or can I show up with DSL's Matterhorn and collect $5000?
 

Attachments

  • Natural BS.png
    Natural BS.png
    207.7 KB · Views: 0
Re: 5K$ anyone?

Marjan Milosevic said:
ATTENTION ALL SPEAKER MANUFACTURES!!!! Canadian Speaker Works will be running our shoot out again this summer 6 of your subs vs 6 of ours..
this will take place In Brampton, Ont Canada this summer $5,000.00 Bet winner take all..

Home - Canadian Speaker Works Pro
https://www.facebook.com/pro.csw?fref=ts

2 x 18'' 'black box'

Canadian Speaker Works - YouTube
Click to expand...
How is the "winner determined? SPL at what freq? low freq extension? output per cubic foot, sensitivity? price per SPL?

There can be all kinds of "winners" in different categories. Is there a limit to the physical size?
 
Re: 5K$ anyone?

I'd like to see Ivan show up with 6 Matterhorns.

Of course, $5k will not cover the truck freight for six of those things both ways and a fork truck rental up there to move them around.

I'd really like to be present when six of those are fired up at once. That would be pretty stunning.

As it is, however... six of the TH-812's would be pretty out of control, too... and it would be WAY cheaper to ship those since you could fit them all in one container instead of shipping six containers.
 
Re: 5K$ anyone?

Marjan Milosevic said:
Ivan, i asked the same question. The answer was "Just bring your subs and set your own rules". So they are very confident that they can win against pretty much everything. They say one of their subs kills 3 Adamson T21.
Click to expand...
They seem to set their own computational and measurement rules :^).
Response 15 Hz 250Hz: at the downward slope of the graph 25 Hz is about 10 dB down from 50 Hz, and 15 Hz is 30+ dB down, the port would be useful as a fan driven with more than a few watts that low.

A 2 x 18" front load bin could measure as the chart shows if measured directly in front of the cabinet center, at around 8 inches (20 centimeters), then to the side at 8", then to the rear at 8"= approximately doubling the distance from the source each time would result in a 12 dB reduction as pictured.
Do the same at a few meters and the cabinet would measure omni other than in the HF.

142 dB peak figures OK with no power compression from 97 dB sensitivity driven with 4949 peak watts (what happens at 5000?), so two cabinets on paper do 148 dB, four cabinets, 154 dB, but hey presto- 3 units stacked per side magically produce 163 dB!

Art
 

Attachments

  • Black box.png
    Black box.png
    413.5 KB · Views: 1
Re: 5K$ anyone?

I'll chip in 50$ if we can get 80 or so ppl to chip in to pay for the shipping to see their face when the danley boxes show up :)
 
Re: 5K$ anyone?

Marjan Milosevic said:
ATTENTION ALL SPEAKER MANUFACTURES!!!! Canadian Speaker Works will be running our shoot out again this summer 6 of your subs vs 6 of ours..
this will take place In Brampton, Ont Canada this summer $5,000.00 Bet winner take all..

Home - Canadian Speaker Works Pro
https://www.facebook.com/pro.csw?fref=ts

2 x 18'' 'black box'

Canadian Speaker Works - YouTube
Click to expand...

Looks like they're getting quite a bit of mileage out of their $5k spent on marketing...
 
Craig Hauber said:
Why do they suck? -would honestly like to know. (They do use up quite a bit of DSP resources on the boxes I've seen it available in)

-sorry for the topic swerve.
Click to expand...

Check out rane note 160.

People may mention poorer transient response and phase shift that looks like an x games trick, but I would say the thing I hear the most is more inconsistencies in lobing and off axis response due to driver positions.
 
Re: 5K$ anyone?

Art,

I'm confused how 142 db figures correctly from 97db 1w sensitivity with 4949 watts. I am asking not because I doubt you but because I want to see where I am wrong.

I would figure at 10 db for every 10 fold increase in power so 10w is 107db, 100w is 117db, 1000w is 127db, 2000w is 130db, 4000w is 133 db. So by my RUDIMENTARY math it would take 10,000w to get to 137db and in the range of 35,000w to get to 142 from 97db 1w sensitivity (assuming no power compression:-)

Where am I wrong. I am sure there is a very simple formula I am missing that can make this clear to me.

Thanks,
Loren
 
Re: 5K$ anyone?

Math retard here but I'm trying to learn.

So 45 db gain (142-97).

then 10log(1w:xw)=45

then log(1w:xw)=4.5

then log(x)=4.5

then x = 10^4.5

then x = 31,622

Am I way off?

or

10log (1w:4949w)=x

10log (4949)=x

10(3.69)=x

x=36.9db

so 97db1w/1m plus 36.9db gain for 4949 watts comes out to 133.9db calculated max output.

Anyway, I am a math loser and need education on something even this elementary. What am I missing?

Thanks,
Loren
Loren Jones said:
Art,

I'm confused how 142 db figures correctly from 97db 1w sensitivity with 4949 watts. I am asking not because I doubt you but because I want to see where I am wrong.

I would figure at 10 db for every 10 fold increase in power so 10w is 107db, 100w is 117db, 1000w is 127db, 2000w is 130db, 4000w is 133 db. So by my RUDIMENTARY math it would take 10,000w to get to 137db and in the range of 35,000w to get to 142 from 97db 1w sensitivity (assuming no power compression:-)

Where am I wrong. I am sure there is a very simple formula I am missing that can make this clear to me.

Thanks,
Loren
Click to expand...
 
Re: 5K$ anyone?

Loren Jones said:
Art,

I'm confused how 142 db figures correctly from 97db 1w sensitivity with 4949 watts. I am asking not because I doubt you but because I want to see where I am wrong.

I would figure at 10 db for every 10 fold increase in power so 10w is 107db, 100w is 117db, 1000w is 127db, 2000w is 130db, 4000w is 133 db. So by my RUDIMENTARY math it would take 10,000w to get to 137db and in the range of 35,000w to get to 142 from 97db 1w sensitivity (assuming no power compression:-)

Where am I wrong. I am sure there is a very simple formula I am missing that can make this clear to me.

Thanks,
Loren
Click to expand...
My mistake, I can't read my own writing on the back of envelopes sometimes.

97 at 1 watt, 107 at 10, 117 at 100, 127 at 1000, 137 at 10,000 -3dB for 5000 (4949) would only be 134 db, and the 35,000w for 142 would be fun to watch.

Makes the claim of 163 dB from 3 cabinets even more laughable.
 
Re: 5K$ anyone?

Art Welter said:
My mistake, I can't read my own writing on the back of envelopes sometimes.

97 at 1 watt, 107 at 10, 117 at 100, 127 at 1000, 137 at 10,000 -3dB for 5000 (4949) would only be 134 db, and the 35,000w for 142 would be fun to watch.

Makes the claim of 163 dB from 3 cabinets even more laughable.
Click to expand...
So if you "give them" the 142dB (not sure where the extra 8dB comes from-unless it is from peak in the response well outside of the intended operating range-it would not be the first (or last) time that has been done-then you have 9dB for 3 cabinets vs 1. So you are at 151dB.

In "some" situations you can gain an extra bit of gain due to boundary loading caused by the other cabinets-but this is not going to happen with that type of cabinet and only 3. So now there is a "mysterious" extra 12 dB coming from somewhere.

So if you add the 12dB and the 8dB you get 20dB. That is only a factor of ONE HUNDRED that they are off. WOW if my car could perform as if it had 30,000 horsepower-instead of the 300 it now has I could have a lot of fun------------. NO BENNETT-you would not be allowed to drive it!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Numbers do matter-and how they are determined really matters. But as long as people don't "question" then manufacturers will continue to put out whatever they think the buyers like.
 
Top Bottom