Hi All,
As I mentioned over the course of a couple of earlier posts,
- I sent in a console to get the monitor whine fixed, among other things;
- It came back with that problem unfixed, with the tech saying "problem could not be found";
- My monitor guy Matt later sent his personal X32 in to get the monitor whine fixed, along with a printout showing an FFT window of the problem;
- It came back with a note saying the "noise reduction fix" or something similar had been done.
Tonight I finally got a chance to SIM his console and compare it to the one that came back unfixed, and lo and behold, his console is 6 db quieter than mine at the noise peaks.
This is the unfixed console. Notice the 6kHz peak and how much higher it is than the reference line:
View attachment 7740
This is the fixed console. Just clears the reference line, and there's some other stuff that's cleaned up as well.
View attachment 7741
Here are the two superimposed. Not as easy to see as would be nice (there's a red X on the peak tracking cursor). That 6k peak is the highest.
View attachment 7742
Here's the values readout, showing a little over 6db improvement.
View attachment 7743
Although the 6k tone is still there if you listen for it, it is much more down in the noise. A few more db and it would be indistinguishable from the noise floor.
The studio guys would have to decide for sure, but I would think the noise would still be unacceptable for listening to control room monitors. I think it's probably also unacceptable for monitorworld, but it's a closer call now than it was. And the option of routing the monitor outs through any of the other 16 analog outputs, which are all quiet, is still available.
So they fixed his, why couldn't they fix mine?
Still, I'm happy that there's at least a partial solution, when they choose to provide it.